The difference is how the window attaches to the house. A new construction window has a nailing fin, a flat flange around the outside of the frame that the crew nails through the sheathing into the framing before the siding goes on. A replacement window has no nailing fin. It goes into an opening that already has a frame, trim and siding around it. The crew fastens it through its own frame from inside the opening. If the wall is open to the sheathing, you want new construction windows. If the siding and trim are staying, you want replacement windows.
What the nailing fin is for
The fin holds the window in the opening, but its bigger job is keeping water out. The sill flashing goes in first. The window is then set in a framed rough opening that's a little larger than the frame, leveled, shimmed and fastened through the fin. The jamb flashing laps over the side fins and the head flashing laps over the top fin, then tucks under the house wrap above. Each layer laps like shingles, so water runs out over the next one down instead of behind it.
The installation instructions spell out the order and the inspector can ask to see them. Window mistakes that fail inspection covers the flashing order and the other things that get caught at the energy and final inspections.
How replacement windows go in
Replacement windows come in a few forms. The common one is an insert window. The old sashes come out, the old frame stays and the new window slides inside it and gets fastened and sealed to that frame. Because the new frame sits inside the old one, you lose some glass area compared with the original window.
A flush-fin window has a flange on its face instead of a nailing fin. It's made for replacing old windows in stucco walls, where the flange covers the edge of the old opening so the stucco doesn't have to be cut back.
Both types depend on the existing opening being sound and dry. If the old frame is rotten or the wall behind it has been taking water, a replacement window just covers the problem up.
Which one a builder needs
On a new house the answer is new construction windows. The openings are framed for them and the water management of the wall is built around the fin and the flashing.
Additions are the same. The new walls get new construction windows and the flashing ties into the new house wrap.
Remodels are where it splits. If the siding is coming off anyway, new construction windows are usually the better choice because you can flash them the same way you would on a new house. If the siding and trim are staying, replacement windows save tearing into a finished wall.
Can a new construction window be used as a replacement?
Yes, if you open the wall around it. The crew removes the old window, cuts back enough siding and trim to reach the sheathing, sets the new window on its fin and flashes it like new work. Then the siding gets patched. It costs more labor than an insert, but the window ends up flashed the right way and you keep the full glass size.
Don't cut the fin off to squeeze a new construction window into an old frame unless the window's installation instructions allow it. On most units the fin is part of how the window sheds water.
Sizing works differently
New construction windows are ordered against the rough opening, the framed hole in the wall. On a nail-fin window the frame is usually a little smaller than the opening, often half an inch in each direction, so the crew has room to level and shim. The exact allowance depends on the manufacturer, so check before the framing starts.
Replacement windows are sized from the existing frame. The measurement is taken inside the old frame at several points and the smallest number wins, because the old opening is rarely square after years in the wall.
The energy code covers both
Windows in a new Washington home have to meet the U-factor on the energy form. Replacement windows in an existing house generally have to meet the same code table. In both cases the code lets you average U-factors across the windows by area. The prescriptive limit is U-0.30 today, measured on the whole window. That number is printed on the NFRC label.
Code editions change. The edition that applies depends on your permit date. Confirm current requirements with your plans examiner before you order. What Washington's energy code requires for windows explains the paths and the numbers.
How the purchase usually works
Replacement windows are often sold to homeowners with installation included. New construction windows are more often bought as a supply package for a builder whose crew or installer sets them. That changes what you compare on a quote. On a supply package you're comparing the windows, the glass, the ratings and the delivery date. How to compare window quotes walks through that line by line.
Where we fit
Our windows are built for new construction. Each one has a vinyl frame with an integral nailing fin and is made to the rough openings on your schedule. We supply five lines to builders in Washington: single hung, horizontal slider, casement, picture window and sliding patio door, in white or black. Every unit ships with its NFRC label and lead time is 11 to 12 weeks from a locked order to the job site. Send us your window schedule and we'll price it.