For most new homes in Washington, vinyl windows meet the energy code for less money than fiberglass. Fiberglass earns its higher price in a few situations: big dark-framed windows facing hot afternoon sun, houses where the owner wants to paint the windows later and designs that call for slim frames around large glass. Everywhere else, a good vinyl window with the right glass does the same job on the energy form and at inspection.
We supply vinyl windows, so read this knowing which side of the counter we're on.
The glass does most of the energy work
Most of a window's area is glass, so the glass package carries most of the energy performance. The Low-E coating, the gas fill and the spacer between the panes all move the number. Frame material matters too, but a vinyl window and a fiberglass window with similar glass can land close together.
What counts for code is the whole-window U-factor on the NFRC label, not the material in the frame. Washington's prescriptive limit for windows is U-0.30 today. Compare the labeled numbers for the exact units on your schedule. How to read an NFRC window label shows where to find them. Code editions change, so confirm the current requirement for your permit with your plans examiner.
Fiberglass moves less with heat
Every frame grows a little in the heat and shrinks in the cold. Vinyl moves more than fiberglass does. Fiberglass moves at close to the same rate as the glass it holds. On a standard-size window in a light color you won't notice it. It counts more on large units and on dark frames, because a dark frame in direct sun runs much hotter than a white one.
If the design has big black windows on a west wall, ask each supplier you're pricing how their dark frames handle heat at those sizes. Get the answer in writing with the quote.
Fiberglass is stiffer
A stiffer material can span the same opening with a narrower frame. That's why fiberglass windows often have slimmer frames and a little more glass for the same rough opening. Vinyl frames are usually wider. Large vinyl units commonly get metal reinforcement inside the frame to stiffen them.
On a production house this seldom decides anything. For a custom home with tall picture windows and an architect who cares about sightlines, it can.
Color is chosen at the order
A vinyl window's color is set at the factory, so the color you order is the color you live with. Vinyl isn't meant to be repainted on site, so lock the frame color before the order goes in. Fiberglass frames can usually be painted later, which matters to an owner who expects to change the exterior color in ten years.
Fiberglass costs more
How much more depends on the brands, the sizes and the glass. The only way to know is to price your own schedule both ways and compare the totals against what the extra money buys on that house.
On a rental or a spec home the extra is hard to earn back. On a custom home with large dark windows it might be worth it.
How to decide on a real job
Start with the energy form and the elevations.
- If every window is a standard size in a light color, vinyl will do the job at a lower price.
- If the plans show large dark windows facing south or west, price fiberglass and ask the vinyl supplier about size limits on dark frames before you choose.
- If the owner wants to paint the windows later, fiberglass is the material that allows it.
- If the architect has drawn thin frames around big glass, fiberglass will get closer to the drawing.
Nothing stops you from mixing the two on one house, with fiberglass on the big west wall and vinyl everywhere else. The frames won't look identical side by side, so keep each material to its own elevation.
Whichever you choose, the checks before ordering are the same. Every window type meets its number on the energy form. The tempered units are marked where the code needs them. Bedroom windows meet egress. How to compare window quotes goes through those checks line by line.
Where we fit
We supply vinyl windows factory-direct to builders in Washington. There are five lines: single hung, horizontal slider, casement, picture window and sliding patio door, with frames in white or black. With our standard glass the certified U-factors are 0.30 for the single hung, 0.27 for the slider, 0.29 for the casement, 0.28 for the picture window and 0.27 for the patio door. Each unit ships with its NFRC label. Lead time is 11 to 12 weeks from a locked order to the job site. If your plans call for fiberglass, we're not the right supplier for those windows. If vinyl fits the house, send us your window schedule and we'll price it.